A Comparative Assessment of Manual Load Lifting Using NIOSH Equation and WISHA Index Methods in Industrial Workers of Shiraz City

Naeimeh Asadi, Alireza Choobineh, Sareh Keshavarzi, Hadi Daneshmandi

Abstract


Background: Manual load lifting is the most common and stressful activity that imposes high biomechanical pressures on the body, particularly on the back. Diverse studies have shown that load lifting can cause work-related musculoskeletal disorders among workers. This study was conducted to assess manual lifting activity using NIOSH equation and WISHA index and compare the results of the two methods in workers with manual lifting activities.

Methods: This cross- sectional study was carried out among 120 workers with manual lifting activity in 7 industrial settings of Shiraz city. Nordic Musculoskeletal disorders Questionnaire (NMQ) and demographic questionnaire, as well as NIOSH lifting equation and WISHA index were used to gather the required data. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS, 19.

Results: The results showed that back problems were the most frequent musculoskeletal disorders among the workers studied (68.3%). The results of lifting evaluation indicated that 79.2% of the individuals in the NIOSH method and 39.2% in WISHA index were at risk of back injuries. The kappa value was equal to 0.29, indicating a fair agreement between the results of assessment by the two methods.

Conclusion: The results of this study confirmed a fair correlation between these two assessment methods, so they might be used interchangeably.


Keywords


Lifting, NIOSH equation, WISHA index, Musculoskeletal disorders

Full Text:

PDF

References


Faghih MA, Motamedzade M, Mohammadi H, Habibi

MM, Bayat H, Arassi M, et al. Manual Material

Handling Assessment by Snook tables in Hamadan

casting workshops. Iran Occupational Health 2013;

(1): 60-7. [persian]

Sadeghi Naeini H. The principles of Ergonomics in

Materials Handling Systems. Publications Asana ed.

Tehran: asana; 2000. p. 43. [persian]

Motamedzade M, Dormohammadi A, Amjad Sardrodi

H, Zarei E, Dormohammadi R. The role of ergonomic

design and application of NIOSH method in improving

the safety of load lifting tasks. Arak Medical University

Journal 2013; 16(75): 90-100. [persian]

Lin CJ, Wang SJ, Chen HJ. A field evaluation method

for assessing whole body biomechanical joint stress

in manual lifting tasks. Industrial health 2006; 44(4):

-12.

Straker L. A critical appraisal of manual handling

risk assessment literature: International Ergonomics

Association Press; 1997.

Mohammadian MM, Motamedzade M, Faradmal J.

investigating the correlations of OCRA index, strain

index and ACGIH HAL methods for assessing the

risk of upper limb muskoloskeletal disorders. Journal

of Ergonomics 2013; 1(2): 63-71. [persian]

Moussa MM. Review on health effects related to

mobile phones Part II: results and conclusions. The 1.

Kulin J, Reaston M. Musculoskeletal disorders early

diagnosis: A retrospective study in the occupational medicine setting. Journal of Occupational Medicine

and Toxicology 2011; 6(1).

Lundholm L, Swartz H. musculoskeletal ergonomics in

the construction industry. Facts & figures in brief No.

2006. Swedish Work Environment Authority 2006.

Dempsey PG. Psychophysical Approach to task

analysis. Fundamentals and assessment tools for

occupational ergonomics Second ed London: Taylor

& Francis 2006: 918-48.

Kuiper JI, Burdorf A, Verbeek JHAM, Frings-Dresen

MHW, van der Beek AJ, Viikari-Juntura ERA.

Epidemiologic evidence on manual materials handling

as a risk factor for back disorders: a systematic review.

International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 1999;

(4): 389-404.

Reid CR, McCauley Bush P, Karwowski W, Durrani

SK. Occupational postural activity and lower extremity

discomfort: A review. International Journal of Industrial

Ergonomics 2010; 40(3): 247-56.

Russell SJ, Winnemuller L, Camp JE, Johnson PW.

Comparing the results of five lifting analysis tools.

Applied Ergonomics 2007; 38(1): 91-7.

Sadeghi S, Nourgostar S, Alibeygi N, Bidari A.

Demographic differences among workers with and

without chronic occupationallow back pain in a steel

plant. Iranian Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery 2006;

(2): 143-8. [persian]

National Safety Council [Online]. 1991; Available from:

URL: www.nsc.org/.

Randall SB, Jeter G. A Guide to Manual Materials

Handling and Back Safety: Division of Occupational

Safety and Health, North Carolina Department of

Labor; 1997.

Abedini R, Choobineh A, Soltanzadeh A, Gholami M,

Amiri F, Hashyani AA. Ergonomic Risk Assessment of

Lifting Activities; a Case Study in a Rubber Industry.

Jundishapur J Health Sci 2013; 5(1): 9-15. [persian]

Kuorinka I, Jonsson B, Kilbom A, Vinterberg H,

Biering-Sørensen F, Andersson G, et al. Standardised

Nordic questionnaires for the analysis of musculoskeletal

symptoms. Applied ergonomics 1987; 18(3): 233-7.

Tayyari F, Smith JL. Manual Materials Handling.

Occupational ergonomics: principles and applications.

first Edition 1997 ed: Chapman & Hall London; 1997.

p 192-207.

Waters TR, Putz-Anderson V, Garg A, National

Institute for Occupational S, Health. Applications

manual for the revised NIOSH lifting equation 1994.

Abdoli Armky M. Manual Material Handling. Body

mechanics and principles of work station design

(ergonomics). Tehran: Omid Majd; 2001. p 161-8.

[persian]

Choobineh A. manual lifting activity. A guide to

human factors and ergonomics. Shiraz 2001. p. 115-16.

[persian]

Keikha moghaddam aa. Ergonomics Assessment Methoda Selection and Application Guide. 1. 1 ed.

Tehran: Fanavaran; 2012. p. 145-169. [persian]

WAC 296-62-051, 2000a. Washington State

Ergonomics Rule. Bureau of L abor and I ndustries,

Olympia, Washington.

WAC 296-62-051, 2000b. Explanatory Statement

(RCW 34.05.325.6a). Washington State Ergonomics

Rule. Bureau of Labor and Industries, Olympia,

Washington, pp. 83–6.

Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer

agreement for categorical data. biometrics 1977; 33:

-174.

Landis JR, Koch GG. An application of hierarchical

kappa-type statistics in the assessment of majority

agreement among multiple observers. Biometrics 1977;

: 363-74. 27 Viera AJ, Garrett JM. Understanding interobserver

agreement: the kappa statistic. Fam Med 2005; 37(5):

-3.

Rahimabadi S, Khanjani N, Mardi H. The prevalence

of musculoskeletal disorders and their related factors

in workers of a dairy factorynishabur, iran. Journal

of Health & Development 2012; 1(2): 121-9. [persian]

Choobineh AR, Tabatabaei SHR, Mokhtarzadeh A,

Salehi M. (2007). Musculoskeletal problems among

workers of an Iranian rubber factory. Journal of

Occupational Health 2007; 49(5): 418-23.

Choobineh AR, Esmailian A, Mohammadbigi A.

Prevalence of work related musculoskeletal disorders

in Steel Production Structures. Iran J Epidemiol 2009;

(5): 35-43. [persian]


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.

pISSN: 2345-2218          eISSN: 2345-3893