Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 Dept. of Clinical Psychology, Faculty of Education and Psychology, Shiraz University, Shiraz, IR Iran.

2 Research Center for Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, IR Iran.

Abstract

Background: Effective common factors such as therapeutic alliance and group cohesion play essential roles in outcome treatment in borderline personality disorder. The present study aimed to investigate the role of therapeutic alliance and group cohesion in group therapy based on mentalization and dialectical behavior in borderline personality disorder.
Methods: This is a single-blind randomized controlled clinical trial conducted on 36 patients diagnosed with BPD (12 in each three groups). They were examined by a semi-structured clinical interview. Data were collected from March 2017 to June 2017. All screening and performance procedures were performed daily in Hefez hospital, Shiraz. Patients were selected through targeted sampling. Data were entered into SPSS, version 21, by using repeated measures and simple regression analysis and analyzed by one who was blind to the groups. The computer method was used for randomization. The participants were categorized into intervention and control groups. Before, immediately and two months after the intervention, the participants filled out the Borderline Personality Disorder Severity Index (BPDSI), Working Alliance Inventory (WAI), Group Cohesion Scale (GCS), Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI), and Beck Depression Inventory-II (BDI-II) questionnaires.
Results: After the intervention, therapeutic alliance (p=0.005) and group cohesion (p=0.0001) in both experimental groups had significantly higher scores compared to the control group.
Conclusion: The two relationship elements were found to contribute to psychotherapy outcome. Therapeutic alliance and group cohesion had also been estimated to account for at least as much variance in psychotherapy outcome as specific therapeutic interventions.

Keywords

1-Bo S, Sharp C, Fonagy P, Kongerslev M. Hypermentalizing, attachment, and epistemic trust in adolescent BPD: Clinical illustrations. Personal Disord: Theory, Research, and Treatment. 2017; 8(2), 172-82.

2-Stoffers JM, Voellm BA, Rücker G, Timmer A, Huband N, Lieb K. Psychological therapies for people with borderline        personality disorder. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012; 15(8). doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD005652.pub2

3-Folmo EJ, Karterud SW, Kongerslev MT, Kvarstein EH, Stänicke E. Battles of the Comfort Zone: Modelling Therapeutic Strategy, Alliance, and Epistemic Trust-A Qualitative Study of Mentalization-Based Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder. J Contemporary Psychotherapy. 2019; 22: 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10879-018-09414-3

4-Norcross JC, Lambert MJ.  Psychotherapy relationships that work III. Psychotherapy. 2018; 55(4): 303-15. doi: 10.1037/pst0000193

5-Norcross JC, Wampold BE. Evidence-based therapy relationships: Research conclusions and clinical practices. In: Norcross JC, editor. Psychotherapy relationships that work: Evidence-based responsiveness. New York, NY, US: Oxford University Press; 2011. p. 423-30. doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199737208.003.0021

6-Bateman َA, Campbell C, Luyten P, Fonagy P. A mentalization-based approach to common factors in the treatment of borderline personality disorder. Curr Opin Psycho. 2018; 21: 44-9. doi: 10.1016/j.copsyc.2017.09.005

7-Schnur JB, Montgomery GH. A systematic review of therapeutic alliance, group cohesion, empathy, and goal consensus/collaboration in psychotherapeutic interventions in cancer: Uncommon factors?. Clin Psychol Rev. 2010;30(2):238-47. doi:10.1016/j.cpr.2009.11.005

8-Coppock O, Owen J, Zagarskas E, Schmidt M. The relationship between therapist and client hope with therapy outcomes. Psychother Res. 2010; 20: 619–26. doi: 10.1080/10503307.2010.497508

9-Greiff NV, Skogens L. Understanding the concept of the therapeutic alliance in group treatment for alcohol and drug problems. European Journal of Social Work. 2017; 20: 69-81. doi: 10.1080/13691457.2017.1341388

10-Norton PJ, Kazantzis N. Dynamic relationships of therapist alliance and group cohesion in transdiagnostic group CBT for anxiety disorders. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2016;84(2):146–155. doi:10.1037/ccp0000062

11-Robak RW, Kangos KA, Chiffriller SH, Griffin PW. The working alliance in group counseling: an exploratory study. Psychol Rep. 2013; 113(2): 591-604.

12-Ardito RB, Rabellino D. Therapeutic Alliance and Outcome of Psychotherapy: Historical Excursus, Measurements, and Prospects for Research. Front Psychol. 2011; 2: 270. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2011.00270

13-Barber JP, Connolly MB, Crits-Christoph P, Gladis L, Siqueland L. Alliance predicts patients’ outcome beyond in-treatment change in symptoms. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment. 2009; S1:80–89. doi: 10.1037/1949-2715.S.1.80

14-Cooper AA, Strunk DR, Ryan ET, DeRubeis RJ, Hollon SD, Gallop R. The therapeutic alliance and therapist adherence as predictors of dropout from cognitive therapy for depression when combined with antidepressant medication. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2015; 50: 113-9. doi:10.1016/j.jbtep.2015.06.005

15-Crits-Christoph P, Gibbons MBC, Mukherjee D. Psychotherapy process-outcome research. In: Lambert MJ, editor. Bergin and Garfield’s handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change. New York: Wiley; 2013. p. 298-340.

16-Flückiger C, Del Re AC, Wampold B, Horvath A.  The Alliance in Adult Psychotherapy: A Meta-Analytic Synthesis. Psychotherapy. 2018; 55. doi: 10.1037/pst0000172.

17-Lo Coco G, Tasca GA, Hewitt PL, Mikail SF, Kivlighan, Jr MD. Ruptures and Repairs of Group Therapy Alliance. An Untold Story in Psychotherapy Research. Research in Psychotherapy: Psychopathology, Process and Outcome. 2019; 22(1): 58-70. doi:10.4081/ripppo.2019.352.

18-Webb CA, DeRubeis RJ, Amsterdam JD, Shelton RC, Hollon SD, Dimidjian S. Two aspects of the therapeutic alliance. J Consult Clin Psycho. 2011; 79:279-83. [PubMed: 21480694]

19-Kivity Y, Levy KN, Kolly S, Kramer U. The Therapeutic Alliance Over 10 Sessions of Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder: Agreement and Congruence Analysis and Relation to Outcome. J Pers Disord. 2019; 28: 1-21. doi: 10.1521/pedi_2019_33_376.

20-Valent EP, Sugiyarti G. Working group cohesiveness of antecedent for successful for performance. Sch. J. Econ. Bus. Manag. 2018; 1141-9. doi: 10.21276/sjebm.2018.5.12.8

21-Kealy D,  Joyce AS, Weber R, Ehrenthal JC, Ogrodniczuk JS. What the patient wants: Addressing patients’ treatment targets in an integrative group psychotherapy programme.Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice. 2018; 92(1): 20-38. doi: 10.1111/papt.12174

22-Burlingame GM, McClendon DT, Yang C. Cohesion in group therapy: A meta-analysis. Psychotherapy. 2018; 55(4): 384-98. doi: 10.1037/pst0000173

23-Greenfield S, Kuper L, Cummings A, Robbins M, Gallop J. Group process in the single-gender women’s recovery group compared with mixed-gender group drug counseling. J Groups Addict Recover. 2013; 8(3): 270-93. doi: 10.1080/1556035X.2013.836867

24-Pooler D, Qualls N, Rogers R, Johnston D. An exploration of cohesion and recovery outcomes in addiction treatment groups. Social Work with Groups. 2014; 37(4): 314-330. doi: 10.1080/01609513.2014.905217

25-Alonso JT. Cohesion's Relationship to Outcome in Group Psychotherapy: A Meta-Analytic Review of Empirical Research. Brigham Young University; 2011. 113p.

26-Burlingame GM, McClendon DT, Alonso J. Cohesion in group therapy. Psychotherapy. 2011; 48(1): 34-42. doi: 10.1037/a0022063.

27-Arntz A, van den Hoorn M, Cornelis J, Verheul R, van den Bosch WM, de Bie AJ. Reliability and validity of the borderline personality disorder severity index. J Pers Disord. 2003; 17(1): 45-59.

28-Horvath AO, Greenberg LS. Development and validation of the Working Alliance Inventory. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 1989; 36(2): 223-33. doi: 10.1037/0022-0167.36.2.223

29-Treadwell T, Lavertue N, Kumar VK, Veeraraghavan V. The Group Cohesion Scale-Revised: Reliability and validity. Int J Action Methods: Psychodrama. Skill Training, and Role Playing. 2001; 54: 3–12.

30-Beck AT, Epstein N, Brown G, Steer RA. An inventory for measuring clinical anxiety: Psychometric properties. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 1988; 56(6): 893-97. doi: 10.1037/0022-006X.56.6.893

31-Kaviani H, Mousavi AS. Psychometric properties of the Persian version of Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI). Tehran Univ Med J. 2008; 65(2):136-40.

32-Beck AT, Steer RA, Brown GK. "Manual for the Beck Depression Inventory-II". San Antonio, TX: Psychological Corporation; 1996.

33-Rahimi C. Application of the Beck Depression Inventory-II in Iranian University Students. CPAP. 2014; 2 (10) :173-88. http://cpap.shahed.ac.ir/article-1-471-fa.html

34-Linehan MM.  Skills training manual for treating borderline personality disorder. 1993; New York: Guilford.

35-Bateman A, Fonagy P. Mentalization based treatment for personality disorders: A practical guide. 2016; Oxford University Press.

36-Stiles WB, Hill CE, Elliott R. Looking both ways. Psychother Res. 2015; 25(3):282-93. [PubMed: 25427829]

37-Piper WE, Ogrodniczuk JS. The therapeutic alliance in group therapy. In: Muran JC, Barber JP, editors. The therapeutic alliance: An evidence-based guide to practice. New York, NY, US: The Guilford Press; 2010. 263-82.

38-Sinnaeve R, van den Bosch LMC, Hakkaart-van Roijen L, Vansteelandt K. Effectiveness of step-down versus outpatient dialectical behaviour therapy for patients with severe levels of borderline personality disorder: a pragmatic randomized controlled trial. Borderline Personal Disord Emot Dysregul. 2018;10(5):12. doi: 10.1186/s40479-018-0089-5

39-Doran JM. The working alliance: Where have we been, where are we going?. Psychotherapy Research. 2016; 26(2), 146-63. doi: 10.1080/10503307.2014.954153

40-Marmarosh CL, Kivlighan DM Jr, Bieri K, Schutt JML, Barone C, Choi J. The insecure psychotherapy base: Using client and therapist attachment styles to understand the early alliance. Psychotherapy. 2014; 51(3):404-12. [PubMed: 24684219].